previous
next

§ 331. “Arising Under Any Laws made by the Parliament.”

In this sub-section the words of the United States Constitution have been accepted without the addition (as in sub-s. i.) of the words “or involving their interpretation;” but the difference seems not to affect the scope of the provision.

“Cases arising under the laws of the United States are such as grow out of the legislation of Congress, within the scope of their constitutional authority, whether they constitute the right, or privilege, or claim, or protection, or defence of the party, in whole or in part, by whom they are asserted.” (Story, Comm. § 1647.) A case may arise under the laws of the Commonwealth in a criminal as well as in a civil suit; and a case arises under a law when it arises under the implication of the law. (Tennessee v. Davis, 100 U.S. 257.)

previous
next